Skip to main content
×
Blacklisted Listed News Logo
Menu - Navigation
Menu - Navigation

Cited Sources

2nd Smartest Guy in the World
2nd Amendment Shirts
10th Amendment Center
Aaron Mate
Activist Post
AIER
Aletho News
Ammo.com
AmmoLand
Alliance for Natural Health, The
Alt-Market
American Free Press
Antiwar
Armstrong Economics
Art of Liberty
AUTOMATIC EARTH, The
Ben Bartee
Benny Wills
Big League Politics
Black Vault, The
BOMBTHROWER
Brandon Turbeville
Breaking Defense
Breitbart
Brownstone Institute
Burning Platform, The
Business Insider
Business Week
Caitlin Johnstone
Campus Reform
CAPITALIST EXPLOITS
Charles Hugh Smith
Children's Health Defense
CHRISTOPHE BARRAUD
Chris Wick
CIAgate
Citizen Free Press
Citizens for Legit Gov.
CNN Money
Collective Evolution
Common Dreams
Conscious Resistance Network
Corbett Report
Counter Signal, The
Cryptogon
Cryptome
Daily Bell, The
Daily Reckoning, The
Daily Veracity
DANERIC'S ELLIOTT WAVES
Dark Journalist
David Haggith
Defense Industry Daily
Defense Link
Defense One
Dennis Broe
DOLLAR COLLAPSE
DR. HOUSING BUBBLE
Dr. Robert Malone
Drs. Wolfson
Drudge Report
Economic Collapse, The
ECONOMIC POPULIST, The
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Ellen Brown
Emerald Robinson
Expose, The
F. William Engdahl
FAIR
Farm Wars
Faux Capitalist
FINANCIAL REVOLUTIONIST
Forbes
Foreign Policy Journal
FOREXLIVE
Foundation For Economic Freedom
Free Thought Project, The
From Behind Enemy Lines
From The Trenches
FUNDIST
Future of Freedom Foundation
Futurism
GAINS PAINS & CAPITAL
GEFIRA
Geopolitical Monitor
Glenn Greenwald
Global Research
Global Security
GM RESEARCH
GOLD CORE
Grayzone, The
Great Game India
Guadalajara Geopolitics
Helen Caldicott
Homeland Sec. Newswire
Human Events
I bank Coin
IEEE
IMPLODE-EXPLODE
Information Clearing House
Information Liberation
Infowars
Insider Paper
Intel News
Intercept, The
Jane's
Jay's Analysis
Jeff Rense
John Adams
John Pilger
John W. Whitehead
Jonathan Cook
Jon Rappoport
Jordan Schachtel
Just The News
Kevin Barret
Kitco
Last American Vagabond, The
Lew Rockwell
Le·gal In·sur·rec·tion
Libertarian Institute, The
Libertas Bella
LIBERTY BLITZKRIEG
LIBERTY Forcast
Liberty Unyielding
Market Oracle
Market Watch
Maryanne Demasi
Matt Taibbi
Medical Express
Media Monarchy
Mercola
Michael Snyder
Michael Tracey
Middle East Monitor
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
Military Info Tech
Mind Unleashed, The
Mint Press
MISES INSTITUTE
Mises Wire
MISH TALK
Money News
Moon of Alabama
Motherboard
My Budget 360
Naked Capitalism
Natural News
New American, The
New Eastern Outlook
News Deck
New World Next Week
Nicholas Creed
OF TWO MINDS
Off-Guardian
Oil Price
OPEN THE BOOKS
Organic Prepper, The
PANDEMIC: WAR ROOM
PETER SCHIFF
Phantom Report
Pierre Kory
Political Vigilante
Public Intelligence
Rair
Reclaim The Net
Revolver
Richard Dolan
Right Turn News
Rokfin
RTT News
Rutherford Institute
SAFEHAVEN
SAKER, The
Shadow Stats
SGT Report
Shadowproof
Slay News
Slog, The
SLOPE OF HOPE
Solari
South Front
Sovereign Man
Spacewar
spiked
SPOTGAMMA
Steve Kirsch
Steve Quayle
Strange Sounds
Strike The Root
Summit News
Survival Podcast, The
Tech Dirt
Technocracy News
Techno Fog
Terry Wahls, M.D.
TF METALS REPORT
THEMIS TRADING
Tom Renz
True Activist
unlimited hangout
UNREDACTED
Unreported Truths
Unz Review, The
VALUE WALK
Vigilant Citizen
Voltaire
Waking Times
Wall Street Journal
Wallstreet on Parade
Wayne Madsen
What Really Happened
Whitney Webb
winter oak
Wolf Street
Zero Hedge

New Variant, New Travel Restrictions, New Lockdowns

Published: November 28, 2021 | Print Friendly and PDF
  Gab
Share

Cases are rising in multiple European nations, prompting lockdowns. Most notably, Portugal, which was has been praised for high rates of vaccination (87%) has again locked down.

Also in the news: a new variant of concern has been noted by the World Health Organization, and markets are down in fear of this news.  The United States and many European nations have closed the border to 8 counties in southern Africa

Here are some thoughts.

1. Travel closures are a blunt policy intervention, and many people have argued that they are stupid—the virus is already in the house by the time you lock the door. Here are quotes from Stef Baral and Wes Pegden on the topic.

I think Stef is almost surely correct that the virus has already reached nations by the time one closes the border. Thus, the policy question of travel bans is: is the marginal benefit of decreasing or diminishing the seed load of the new strain in your nation (through the ban) worth the downside of disrupted commence and human misery that the ban imposes?

One should assume that already some amount of the new variant is already on your shores, and thus the benefit is the marginal change in that variant’s starting point. One must also assume that it is not hard to get around the travel ban, by traveling to a 3rd country before reaching your final destination.

Put that way, I am confident that both Stef and Wes are right and this is a fools’ errand, but like most things in the pandemic, there is still some uncertainty here.

2. Lockdowns. Portugal locking down is evidence that even if a nation has an 86% vaccination rate—a rate that is truly remarkable—that does not mean cases/ health systems load will necessarily be under control. This fact seriously undermines a tacit claim for vaccine mandates in the USA. The USA’s use of adult mandates aspires to push the vaccination rate to 86% (it will likely be a couple percentage points, as I argue elsewhere), but even if it did, we see now from Portgual that this rate of vaccination does not guarantee the broader health goal (ending the potential for high cases and hospitalizations across a population), which many tacitly implied was the justification for the mandate.

Put another way, the state justifies the force of the mandate because it will result in a shared public benefit, but Portugal undermines this justification. I suspect the downsides of mandates on broader political processes and life will far exceed the upside at least in the USA. And let the record also state that the way to judge vaccine mandates as a policy intervention is to look at the gains in vaccination (good) but subtract the people pushed out of the labor force, displaced from society, and downstream political consequences (bad).

3. It is embarrassing we don’t have more cluster randomized clinical trials of masking. Bangladesh is the only one reported to date (more to come on that in a future post). But none have been done in high income nations. None have been done in kids. None have been done for people post vaccine. None have been done in places with natural immunity. None have been done in cities.

Yet, as pathetic as it is to not have any credible data that our masking policies (PS – mostly cloth masking policies) work, and continue to implement and reimplement them for years with attendant moral shaming, it is far worse to continue to implement lockdown measures without knowing whether, and if so under what circumstances, they work (i.e. provide net health benefit). 

We truly do not know if the actions taken in Austria, the Netherlands, Portugal etc. will result in a long term net health benefit to the community. The lockdown critics have been unfairly silenced and demonized. As we keep re-instituting these draconian measures some better evidence is needed, or we must abandon these as tools. A politician looks strong when they use these tools, but do they merely bring more misery on the citizenry?

4.     We have become de-sensitized to these interventions (Lockdown & travel bans), and accordingly we use them more and more.

Recently, I talked about the history of removing our shoes at the airport, which began in the USA in 2006, and has continues to this day.  Of course, only for folks who can’t afford TSA-Precheck! Shall we note the analogies?

Shoe removal had a logic in 2006 after the attempted, but unsuccessful shoe bomber.  At the same time, it provides a downside.  It takes time.  If anyone has an empirical analysis, I would love to see it.  I spent some time looking.

Clearly there is a years of life lost by the intervention. The number of people who do it x 30 -90 seconds. This will be massive! And there is a years of life gained by rarely averting a shoe weapon. Does anyone know which is larger? How effective it is? Same is true for all pandemic interventions.

The second analogy is, as was the case throughout the pandemic, the restrictions are not as onerous for the rich.  (TSA Pre-check/ private jets). 

And the third analogy is, after a while, we get used to the inconvenience, and no one questions it anymore. It would be inappropriate to mandate masking season after season without additional cluster randomized clinical trials. Lockdowns are far more onerous with multifaceted impacts, and should be subject to greater scrutiny.

Overall the ongoing events should prompt policy discussions about what the goals of the intervention are, and how we might generate better evidence and set limits on these tools.

Subscribe to the author’s substack for more content from him.

TOP TRENDING ARTICLES


PLEASE DISABLE AD BLOCKER TO VIEW DISQUS COMMENTS

Ad Blocking software disables some of the functionality of our website, including our comments section for some browsers.


Trending Now



BlackListed News 2006-2023
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service